Friday, May 9, 2025
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up
Donate
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
No Result
View All Result
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result

Extraordinary legal spectacle in Pride month as multi-million pound trans focused charities try to silence the only LGB charity, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Home Reports
byLesbian and Gay News
June 5, 2021
in Reports
4 min read
Extraordinary legal spectacle in Pride month as multi-million pound trans focused charities try to silence the only LGB charity, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh
TweetShare

The public campaign against the LGB Alliance by established trans-focused charities Stonewall and Mermaids escalated into litigation today with an appeal against the Charity Commission’s decision to award the LGBA charitable status (available here). This follows ferocious objections from the groups to the initial application for registration and a campaign of well publicised subsequent complaints to the commission itself by supporters of both charities, (many of which were dismissed as “emotional”). It seems then that 2021 Pride month will set the stage for an extraordinary legal spectacle of large, multi-million pound trans focused charities seeking to silence and effectively destroy a lesbian/gay/bisexual focused one. 

The appeal itself is crowdfunded by and appears to be promoted by the non for-profit company “The Good Law Project” but the grounds of appeal themselves name the charity Mermaids as the entity actually appealing the decision. Passing reference is also made to Stonewall who, following a week of high profile exits from its diversity scheme, make complaint that the LGBA is undermining that scheme. This complaint may be hard to reconcile with Equality Minister Liz Truss’ urging of all government bodies to leave the scheme and a damning report into Essex University which found Stonewall represented the law as it wished it to be. The structure of the people complaining therefore appears to be two multi million pound charities and others speaking through a company which in turn crowd funds donations and will retain any excess donations for trans focused litigation.

You may also like

A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

The Miller effect: How the Court of Appeal refashioned freedom of speech, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Lush withdraws decision to fund two lesbian groups after cosmetics retailer feared backlash by trans activists

In order to argue the case the various participants will need to demonstrate they have “standing” so to do. This term is a legal concept which in broad terms requires a party to show they are sufficiently affected by a decision such that the court should entertain their argument. This issue is always considered as a preliminary point in such cases on the basis there is little point in listening to an argument a party is not entitled to make. This could easily turn out to be the key issue in the case and may well be a real challenge in bringing the appeal as a 2009 case where Deputy High Court Judge Lord Carlisle held in a case involving two peace focused charities that the appellant “happens to be interested in the subject area and objects of the other charity and does not agree with the Charity Commission, but in my judgment that is insufficient” to establish standing. In this case Mermaids may struggle to establish that they are even interested in the same subject area as the LGBA.

The grounds themselves rehearse a number of complaints already dealt with by the Charity Commission and so the appeal, to some extent, represents an attempt at having a second bite of the cherry. Perhaps most strikingly, the grounds appear to claim that anything other than complete agreement with the gender identity position is in and of itself a de facto attack on trans focused charities. The grounds specifically complain that Bev Jackson said in March 2020 “We’re applying for charitable status and building an organisation to challenge the dominance of those who promote the damaging theory of gender identity”. The complaint that this speech is enough to make good the objection may be extremely difficult to establish in law given recent the statements by EHRC chair, Baroness Falkner to the effect that a gender critical position is a protected characteristic and the fact the body recently intervened in the Maya Forstater Appeal Case to protect extremely similar speech and thought.

The core of the complaint appears to be that any dissent from a belief in gender identity is political in nature and therefore outside the objectives of a charity. Logically this may be a difficult argument to pursue as it is based on the premise that one side of a discussion is political, but the contrary Stonewall/Mermaids position is somehow above politics or reasoned discussion. The focus on a “political” objection is also difficult to reconcile with the Charity Commission’s decision at paragraph 44; “Charities with purposes for the promotion of human rights may engage in political activities when enforcing rights against states and challenging decisions of government and public bodies.”

The grounds go onto complain that the LGBA believes that trans people should be excluded from charities and communities, in effect, a demand that all gay charities must incorporate trans objectives. As the appeal is at least in name brought by a trans only charity with no public duties to LGB people this may be a difficult argument to logically sustain particularly when set against the fact that prominent trans figures such as Dr. Debbie Hayton regularly voice support for LGBA.

Somewhat remarkably, the grounds also complain that same sex attracted persons who dissent from the gender identity position do not form a sufficient number of people to warrant charitable status, an argument that is in effect a naked “anti-minority” position on its own terms. Further complaint is made that Mermaids specifically will lose out on funding to the LGBA, given the distinct targets and constituencies of the two charities, how such financial effects might logically follow is not immediately obvious.

In a further twist, the precise position of Stonewall was complicated by an amendment to the crowdfunding website which this morning named Stonewall as supporting the action but went onto delete reference to the organisation, it is presently unclear whether Stonewall openly or otherwise support the case.

Dennis Kavanagh is a legal commentator and barrister (non-practising).

Dennis blogs about LGBT issues and law here

Tags: Charity CommissionDennis KavanaghGood Law ProjectLGB AllianceMermaidsStonewall
Previous Post

LGB Alliance “have confidence in the Charity Commission” as trans children’s charity Mermaids leads legal attempt to overturn decision on charity status

Next Post

Professional Judy: “Charities like Mermaids and Stonewall have used our well established organisations as a Trojan horse to push a deeply homophobic ideology.”

Comments 1

The views/opinions expressed in these comments are solely those of the author and do not represent those of Lesbian & Gay News. Please thoroughly read our comment policy before posting.
  1. TrueNorth says:
    4 years ago

    Brilliant explanation - thanks!

    Reply

To view all comments and to join the conversation, please sign in or register.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must sign in to join the conversation.

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Sign in to comment.

Would you like to sign in or register?

TopStories

Jo Bartosch reports on political cartoonist Stella Perrett’s book “2020 The Year We Were All Cancelled”
Books

Jo Bartosch reports on political cartoonist Stella Perrett’s book “2020 The Year We Were All Cancelled”

by Jo Bartosch
April 1, 2021
852
“Viruses do not recognise pronouns”: Use of gender identity by sexual health clinics causes confusion and concerns over data
Reports

“Viruses do not recognise pronouns”: Use of gender identity by sexual health clinics causes confusion and concerns over data

by Lesbian and Gay News
October 1, 2021
2k
“This is a form of conversion therapy for young people who are gay or lesbian.” Watch Dr David Bell on Channel 4 News
Gender Dysphoria

“This is a form of conversion therapy for young people who are gay or lesbian.” Watch Dr David Bell on Channel 4 News

by Lesbian and Gay News
February 26, 2021
1.3k
Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”
Reports

Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
November 14, 2021
513
Ammonite review by Jack Cline: “An earthy same-sex romance, this time on England’s Jurassic Coast in the mid-19th century”
Film

Ammonite review by Jack Cline: “An earthy same-sex romance, this time on England’s Jurassic Coast in the mid-19th century”

by Jack Cline
February 26, 2021
475

RecommendedPosts

Professional Judy: Drag queens and our gay history

Professional Judy on Grindr: “The app for males to meet males has now pivoted and it seems to be an app for anyone to meet anyone.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
July 2, 2021
2.4k

Looking forward to the appeal in Maya Forstater v CGD, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Looking forward to the appeal in Maya Forstater v CGD, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

by Lesbian and Gay News
April 23, 2021
2.7k

Professional Judy: “Why are you wearing a boy’s uniform?” That question has stayed with me since it was first asked by my chemistry teacher in front of a packed class when I was just 13 years old.

Professional Judy: “Why are you wearing a boy’s uniform?” That question has stayed with me since it was first asked by my chemistry teacher in front of a packed class when I was just 13 years old.

by Lesbian and Gay News
August 7, 2021
4.3k

Claire Heuchan talks to author and campaigner Julie Bindel about her new book Feminism for Women: “We’re warriors,” she reminds me. “Lesbians absolutely are sexual outlaws.”

Claire Heuchan talks to author and campaigner Julie Bindel about her new book Feminism for Women: “We’re warriors,” she reminds me. “Lesbians absolutely are sexual outlaws.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
August 29, 2021
1.2k

Tavistock Centre’s gay conversion therapy whistle-blower vindicated in her employment tribunal, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Tavistock Centre’s gay conversion therapy whistle-blower vindicated in her employment tribunal, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

by Lesbian and Gay News
September 10, 2021
3.3k

Kay Knight in praise of butch lesbians: “We are absolutely under attack, and we need grit to withstand the pressure.”

Kay Knight in praise of butch lesbians: “We are absolutely under attack, and we need grit to withstand the pressure.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
December 2, 2021
3k

MostRecent

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

March 27, 2022
7k

Lesbians United on taking back the narrative

March 23, 2022
512

“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

March 23, 2022
820

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

Related Posts

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

March 27, 2022
7k
“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

March 23, 2022
820
The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell

The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell

February 5, 2022
727
Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex

Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex

January 31, 2022
1.5k
A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

January 12, 2022
1.1k
“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

December 31, 2021
4.3k

Next Post
Professional Judy: “Charities like Mermaids and Stonewall have used our well established organisations as a Trojan horse to push a deeply homophobic ideology.”

Professional Judy: “Charities like Mermaids and Stonewall have used our well established organisations as a Trojan horse to push a deeply homophobic ideology.”

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

About Us

Lesbian and Gay News is an alternative source of news and opinion. Lesbian and Gay News picks up from an historic tradition of British lesbian and gay publications such as Gay News, which ran from 1972-1983, and The Pink Paper, which ran for 25 years from 1987.

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Videos
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.