Saturday, June 14, 2025
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up
Donate
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
No Result
View All Result
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result

Jo Bartosch: “This ghoulish trend of trans-ing the dead raises some wider and valid ethical questions.”

Home Opinion
byLesbian and Gay News
April 9, 2021
in Opinion
4 min read
Jo Bartosch: Lost lesbians in the census
TweetShare

I can’t help but applaud the gall of trans activists. Like Trump at his most bombastic; they claim whatever fact, historical figure or cultural quirk takes their fancy and reshape it to fit a political agenda. On Easter Sunday, the Huffington Post ran an article which claimed Jesus was “born genetically female, and yet trans-formed into man.” A flurry of tweets followed which invited comparisons between medieval images of Christ’s bleeding wounds with the mastectomy scars of women who identify as transmen.

As a devout atheist this struck me as darkly funny. In many ways trans activists are following in the sandal-prints of orthodox Christianity; the creepy obsession with mortification of the flesh, the belief in transubstantiation and respect for a revered class of men in frocks. But such attempts by trans activists to colonise history are understandable. A little like ‘plastic paddys’ who cling to their Irish roots despite being fifth-generation American, it is a means to link one’s present to a fantasy past, a way to gain a sense of provenance.

You may also like

Jo Bartosch: “It is the EHRC’s job to look at facts; their intervention has been like the return of adults to the room.”

Gary Powell: “Was it our own internalised homophobia that allowed the gender lobby to hijack our gay rights movement? As though that’s all we are worth?”

Jo Bartosch on how gender critical campaigners are being labelled domestic terrorists and threats to national security by ‘radicalisation’ academics at King’s College London

Professional Judy signs up to Gettr: “As Twitter disappears up its own reality-denying ideological rectum it has become more and more authoritarian.”

In 2019, trans activist, Associate Professor Grace Lavery of Berkeley University, even appropriated George Eliot arguing “The story of George Eliot’s reception is a story of transphobic euphemism. Because the most important British novelist, like it or not, was a trans author.”

Attempts to recast drag queens as having been at the forefront of the Stonewall riots, or to claim that Joan of Arc was a transman, are damaging. Such lies distort the truth and undermine the extraordinary contributions of incredible people. In particular, women who had no option but to use the markers of masculinity to take a position in public life are now routinely marked out as transgender. In 2019, trans activist, Associate Professor Grace Lavery of Berkeley University, even appropriated George Eliot arguing “The story of George Eliot’s reception is a story of transphobic euphemism. Because the most important British novelist, like it or not, was a trans author.”

George Eliot

But this ghoulish trend of trans-ing the dead raises some wider and valid ethical questions about how we describe historical figures that we popularly like to think of as lesbian, gay or bisexual.

It is widely acknowledged that history is written by the victors, and that women and in particular lesbians, are rarely victorious. As such, writing lesbians back into history is a political act, an attempt to undo a patriarchal wrong. But as L.P. Hartley so perfectly captured in the opening line of The Go-Between, “The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there.”

Historians of LGB history have had to battle not only changes in terminology but also in the understanding of human sexuality. The traditional lesbian feminist approach, that heterosexuality is a social construct, has the potential to artificially inflate the numbers of lesbians. Conversely, the definition of homosexuality as understood by most today would exclude all but a few a same-sex attracted people of the past.

There is no objective lens through which to view the past, and it is worth being aware that some of history’s most famous ‘homosexuals’ might not have thought of themselves as gay or lesbian.

It’s easy to forget that customs which are today seen as markers of heterosexuality, such as wedlock or sharing a bed, do not necessarily translate to earlier generations; for every Ann Lister there were many more lesbians married to men. There is no objective lens through which to view the past, and it is worth being aware that some of history’s most famous ‘homosexuals’ might not have thought of themselves as gay or lesbian.

After relationships with women, Sappho, the poetess who gave her name to the word ‘Sapphic,’ was reported to have fallen in love with a ferryman called Phaon. Given that approximately only 3% of her work has survived the two millennia since her death, it’s difficult to authenticate any of the details of her life, but arguably in contemporary terms she might best be described as bisexual rather than lesbian. Despite this, in popular imagination Sappho has become the emblem of female homosexuality. Similarly, Oscar Wilde is generally understood to be the archetype of a gay man; whilst he was disgraced and imprisoned on that basis, he also had loving and sexual relationships with women as a young man.

It’s easy to scoff at the vanity of transgender activists, desperate to see themselves reflected in everyone from Jesus Christ to Kurt Cobain, but historical revisionism is something of which most of us are guilty. Unlike transgender identities, which are a modern phenomenon searching for historic justification, we lesbians, gays and bisexuals have clearly always existed. There’s a comfort, and arguably a duty, to uncover history’s same sex relationships. But we should be aware that our view into the past is obscured by prohibitions and prejudices; there is no way to be free of these, all we do is be aware of our own.

Tags: HistoryJo Bartosch
Previous Post

Yr Alarch Du: Why political lesbianism is a dangerous and divisive fallacy

Next Post

Arty Morty: Graham Linehan’s gender blasphemy exposes the fear that stifles the trans debate

Comments 2

The views/opinions expressed in these comments are solely those of the author and do not represent those of Lesbian & Gay News. Please thoroughly read our comment policy before posting.
  1. Markjp says:
    4 years ago

    An interesting article. As past figures were in a closet and may not have shared our terms it is mostly impossible to say someone was Gay, Lesbian or gender dysphoric. Certain established facts may suggest gender non conformity but that is as far as it goes. History in many ways has few facts but interpretations. I can understand that we all want to see ourselves in the past especially when you are not in the majority. But it is wrong to definitely say that someone was Gay, Lesbian or Bi or gender dysphoric in the vast majority of cases.

    Reply
  2. DC Hampton says:
    4 years ago

    "it is worth being aware that some of history’s most famous ‘homosexuals’ might not have thought of themselves as gay or lesbian." Some of the most famous ones we have today might not either! Hence ludicrous descriptors like MSM (Men Who Have Sex With Men) and WSW (Women Who Have Sex With Women), created to avoid upsetting the sensibilities of people who loathe identification with same-sex desire. James Baldwin said it best: "I can't believe what you say because I see what you do."

    Reply

To view all comments and to join the conversation, please sign in or register.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must sign in to join the conversation.

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Sign in to comment.

Would you like to sign in or register?

TopStories

Fact-checking Forstater – Dealing with the eight Maya Myths, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh
Reports

Fact-checking Forstater – Dealing with the eight Maya Myths, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

by Lesbian and Gay News
May 3, 2021
3.9k
Critiquing transgender theology: A review of Janice Raymond’s ‘Doublethink’ by Robert Jensen, Emeritus Professor of Journalism at the University of Texas
Books

Critiquing transgender theology: A review of Janice Raymond’s ‘Doublethink’ by Robert Jensen, Emeritus Professor of Journalism at the University of Texas

by Lesbian and Gay News
January 23, 2022
2.1k
“This is a form of conversion therapy for young people who are gay or lesbian.” Watch Dr David Bell on Channel 4 News
Gender Dysphoria

“This is a form of conversion therapy for young people who are gay or lesbian.” Watch Dr David Bell on Channel 4 News

by Lesbian and Gay News
February 26, 2021
1.3k
Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”
Reports

Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
November 14, 2021
534
The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell
Reports

The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell

by Gary Powell
February 5, 2022
746

RecommendedPosts

Dysphoric – Fleeing Womanhood Like a House on Fire: An interview with documentary film-maker Vaishnavi Sundar

Dysphoric – Fleeing Womanhood Like a House on Fire: An interview with documentary film-maker Vaishnavi Sundar

by Jo Bartosch
March 4, 2021
4.5k

grayscale photo of people walking beside house

As Pride in London wants 2022 to be “The Year of Queer”, Professional Judy says “We’re not subversive, we’re not unusual, we’re not deviants and we’re not fu**ing Queer”

by Lesbian and Gay News
August 18, 2021
2.3k

Kat Howard: “I want to see more lesbians on my screen like Amy and Kirsten in Vigil, not just as lesbians, but as women too.”

Kat Howard: “I want to see more lesbians on my screen like Amy and Kirsten in Vigil, not just as lesbians, but as women too.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
September 28, 2021
1.6k

Happy Mother’s Day: A tribute to his mother by LGN reader and Camden Councillor Richard Cotton

Happy Mother’s Day: A tribute to his mother by LGN reader and Camden Councillor Richard Cotton

by Lesbian and Gay News
March 17, 2021
364

Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”

Watch Allison Bailey’s Keynote Speech: “Lord Nick Herbert, do not make participation in next year’s global conference on LGBT rights, conditional on LGB people supporting gender identity.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
November 14, 2021
534

Gary Powell: Why we should say no to surrogacy   

Gary Powell: Why we should say no to surrogacy  

by Lesbian and Gay News
June 24, 2021
4.3k

MostRecent

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

March 27, 2022
7k

Lesbians United on taking back the narrative

March 23, 2022
512

“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

March 23, 2022
822

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

Related Posts

Claire Heuchan: Using difference creatively

Claire Heuchan: How do we find more lesbian spaces?

February 23, 2022
1.2k
Shereen Benjamin on Stonewall: “It is alarming that City of Edinburgh councillors would affiliate their council to this increasingly discredited organisation.”

Shereen Benjamin on Stonewall: “It is alarming that City of Edinburgh councillors would affiliate their council to this increasingly discredited organisation.”

February 20, 2022
1.5k
Jo Bartosch: “One might have hoped that Lord Herbert might have questioned the huge rise in rates of referral to gender identity clinics, that he might have met with LGB Alliance.”

Gary Powell: Why Conservative backbench MPs should demand that Boris Johnson cancel the “Safe To Be Me” international LGBT conference

March 1, 2022
1.4k
EHRC skewers the UK Government’s Conversion Therapy proposals, by Bev Jackson from LGB Alliance

EHRC skewers the UK Government’s Conversion Therapy proposals, by Bev Jackson from LGB Alliance

February 7, 2022
2.2k
Jo Bartosch: “It is the EHRC’s job to look at facts; their intervention has been like the return of adults to the room.”

Jo Bartosch: “It is the EHRC’s job to look at facts; their intervention has been like the return of adults to the room.”

February 1, 2022
1.5k
Gary Powell: “The Conservatives’ LGBT ‘conversion therapy’ ban could become their new Section 28.”

Gary Powell: “Was it our own internalised homophobia that allowed the gender lobby to hijack our gay rights movement? As though that’s all we are worth?”

January 26, 2022
2.9k

Next Post
Arty Morty: Graham Linehan’s gender blasphemy exposes the fear that stifles the trans debate

Arty Morty: Graham Linehan’s gender blasphemy exposes the fear that stifles the trans debate

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

About Us

Lesbian and Gay News is an alternative source of news and opinion. Lesbian and Gay News picks up from an historic tradition of British lesbian and gay publications such as Gay News, which ran from 1972-1983, and The Pink Paper, which ran for 25 years from 1987.

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Videos
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.