Saturday, July 19, 2025
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up
Donate
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
No Result
View All Result
Lesbian and Gay News
No Result
View All Result

Maya victorious: Court rules gender critical beliefs are a protected characteristic, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Home Reports
byLesbian and Gay News
June 12, 2021
in News, Reports
4 min read
Looking forward to the appeal in Maya Forstater v CGD, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh
TweetShare

In a judgment with far–reaching implications, the Employment Appeal Tribunal today ruled in favour of Maya Forstater and her claim that gender–critical beliefs qualify for protection under the Equality Act. In an extremely clear judgment, Mr Justice Choudhury ruled that Forstater’s belief in the immutability and importance of biological sex “did not get anywhere near to approaching the kind of belief akin to Nazism or totalitarianism” which fall outside the scope of protection from the act.

The significance of this judgment is difficult to overstate in the context of the gender debate. With gender-critical beliefs now protected, threats of reporting contributors to their employers and a culture of silencing people are highly likely to become things of the past. The court emphasised that freedom of belief and expression are essential foundations of a democratic society and that it is not the place of any court to involve itself in the merits of the debate. Not only will the case have profound implications for employment cases: the judgment is also likely to be of significance in wider attempts to silence gender–critical organisations such as the LGB Alliance, who currently face a concerted group action of trans/LGBT charities arguing their beliefs are not worthy of respect.

You may also like

A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

The Miller effect: How the Court of Appeal refashioned freedom of speech, by LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

Lush withdraws decision to fund two lesbian groups after cosmetics retailer feared backlash by trans activists

The appeal in this case turned on a criterion known as “Grainger V”: this refers to a case called Grainger where five criteria were set down as the legal requirements for a “philosophical belief” before it can qualify for protection under the Equality Act. Grainger V says that a belief must be worthy of respect in a democratic society. The first instance tribunal judgment found against Forstater on this requirement, holding that her views were incorrect scientifically, “absolutist”, and necessarily harmful. In a comprehensive reversal of that judgment the appeal tribunal rejected all three findings. The Appeal tribunal ruled that the lower tribunal should not have got into the scientific debate in the first place and “could be said to have failed to remain neutral” in so doing. The description “absolutist” was comprehensively rejected, with the appeal finding that not only was this incorrect on the evidence, but that it was irrelevant to whether a belief should be protected or not.

The core of the judgment concerns the third finding: the suggestion that gender–critical beliefs are necessarily harmful and therefore unworthy of respect in a democracy. Comprehensively rejecting this finding, the appeal tribunal held that “unworthy of respect” in the context of the Human Rights Act means views that are akin to Nazism or totalitarianism. The Court effectively ruled that only where a person’s belief or exercise of speech are aimed at removing the human rights of others should the belief be held to be unworthy of respect. In other words, the exercise of a human right should not be a device for defeating human rights more generally: a principle enshrined in Article 17 of the HRA itself. Ruling that the lower tribunal had effectively curtailed freedom of speech and conscience, the appellate judgment held, “it is not open to the Tribunal to impose in effect a blanket restriction on a person not to express …views.”

Describing her own view, Forstater said she believes that it was not “incompatible to recognise that human beings cannot change sex whilst also protecting the human rights of people who identify as transgender”. Rejecting the characterisation that such views were unworthy of respect, the appeal court held “That is not, on any view, a statement of a belief that seeks to destroy the rights of trans persons. It is a belief that might in some circumstances cause offence to trans persons, but the potential for offence cannot be a reason to exclude a belief from protection altogether.”

In a Pride month that has seen gender–critical views compared to antisemitism and the word “feminazi” used on Twitter, the judgment is a crystal-clear rebuke of such heightened and extreme positions. Equally, the judgment is at pains to emphasise that it is not a charter to simply act in an offensive manner to trans people and assures readers that trans people will properly be protected by the courts and that harassment of trans people will not be tolerated. With the debate effectively opened up, it is much to be hoped that the measured, tolerant and calm tone of the judgment inspires a free and civilised debate.

Dennis Kavanagh is a legal commentator and barrister (non-practising).

Dennis blogs about LGBT issues and law here

Tags: Dennis KavanaghMaya Forstater
Previous Post

CJ Liberte: I don’t think kink belongs at Pride

Next Post

Book review by Angela Wild: A radfem response to Kathleen Stock’s Material Girls

Comments 4

The views/opinions expressed in these comments are solely those of the author and do not represent those of Lesbian & Gay News. Please thoroughly read our comment policy before posting.
  1. Gary Powell says:
    4 years ago

    This is an excellent result. The problem will come, however, if a future woke govt sympathetic to gender extremism enacts primary legislation to remove the gender-critical protections currently conferred by the Equality Act 2010. It needn't necessarily be a Starmer-led Labour govt ( with the SNP and the Greens), either: the Conservatives are getting gradually colonised by extreme gender ideology, introduced by younger activists & also the LGBT+ Conservatives lobby in the Commons & Lords. This is why the grassroots campaign to educate the public in general about the dangers of extreme gender ideology is so important. The political parties must be made very aware that they will lose votes when they go down that rabbit-hole.

    Reply
  2. Catherine Conroy says:
    4 years ago

    A heartening result but I wish our biological reality would be treated as such, not as a matter of 'belief'. Still, legally at least, it's now providing a safeguard for those who want to speak out.

    Reply
  3. Catherine Conroy says:
    4 years ago

    Yes indeed, and a few men too.

    Reply
  4. Oiorpata says:
    4 years ago

    Time for women who have been discriminated against by their employers to avail themselves of this judgement and claim compensation.

    Reply

To view all comments and to join the conversation, please sign in or register.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must sign in to join the conversation.

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Sign in to comment.

Would you like to sign in or register?

TopStories

Tavistock Centre’s gay conversion therapy whistle-blower vindicated in her employment tribunal, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh
Reports

Tavistock Centre’s gay conversion therapy whistle-blower vindicated in her employment tribunal, writes LGN legal commentator Dennis Kavanagh

by Lesbian and Gay News
September 10, 2021
3.3k
Kay Knight on the death of subtext in LGB films: “We have an industry often so beholden to checkbox ‘representation’ that it has overlooked the need to tell real stories.”
Film

Kay Knight on the death of subtext in LGB films: “We have an industry often so beholden to checkbox ‘representation’ that it has overlooked the need to tell real stories.”

by Lesbian and Gay News
August 23, 2021
1.5k
Labour MP Rosie Duffield’s fight to defend women’s rights
Politics

Labour MP Rosie Duffield’s fight to defend women’s rights

by Jo Bartosch
February 26, 2021
86.3k
Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex
Reports

Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex

by Gary Powell
January 31, 2022
1.5k
US rapper Kurtis Tripp talks to Dennis Kavanagh about conversion therapy at 13, the pressure to identify as trans and his journey back as a gender critical gay rights activist
Gay Lives

US rapper Kurtis Tripp talks to Dennis Kavanagh about conversion therapy at 13, the pressure to identify as trans and his journey back as a gender critical gay rights activist

by Lesbian and Gay News
July 19, 2021
6.8k

RecommendedPosts

Why do lesbian and gay Conservative Party voters find it hard to come out as Tory?

Why do lesbian and gay Conservative Party voters find it hard to come out as Tory?

by Jo Bartosch
February 26, 2021
1.5k

Professional Judy: Drag queens and our gay history

Professional Judy: Straight talking from the super straights on biological sex

by Lesbian and Gay News
March 26, 2021
1.6k

Quotes and Notes – Sunday 21st February

Quotes and Notes – Saturday 20th March

by Lesbian and Gay News
March 26, 2021
97

Yr Alarch Du: Why political lesbianism is a dangerous and divisive fallacy

Yr Alarch Du: Why political lesbianism is a dangerous and divisive fallacy

by Lesbian and Gay News
April 9, 2021
1.5k

Claire Heuchan: Using difference creatively

Claire Heuchan: I’m a proud lesbian, but I won’t go to Pride

by Lesbian and Gay News
June 20, 2021
3.1k

“If we don’t we get a punishment”: No freedom of speech for women in prison says Dr Kate Coleman, Director of Keep Prisons Single Sex

“If we don’t we get a punishment”: No freedom of speech for women in prison says Dr Kate Coleman, Director of Keep Prisons Single Sex

by Lesbian and Gay News
October 12, 2021
4.5k

MostRecent

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

March 27, 2022
7k

Lesbians United on taking back the narrative

March 23, 2022
513

“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

March 23, 2022
823

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

Related Posts

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

Announcement from the LGN Management Team: Lesbian and Gay News is closing

March 27, 2022
7k
“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

“The current model is not sustainable and another model is needed”: Interim Report of Cass Review welcomed by families with transgender-identified children, reports Gary Powell

March 23, 2022
823
The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell

The Government’s Conversion Therapy consultation ends this Friday and Sex Matters – a great ally to lesbian and gay people – have made it easy to respond, reports Gary Powell

February 5, 2022
751
Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex

Reports that Iran has executed two men for gay sex

January 31, 2022
1.5k
A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

A gay man’s long battle to clear his name after 1995 arrest for ‘importuning’ as government expands official pardons, reports Jo Bartosch

January 12, 2022
1.1k
“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

“This year will see transgender ideology in the dock”: 5 legal and political events to watch for in 2022 by Jo Bartosch

December 31, 2021
4.3k

Next Post
Book review by Angela Wild: A radfem response to Kathleen Stock’s Material Girls

Book review by Angela Wild: A radfem response to Kathleen Stock's Material Girls

Categories

  • Activism
  • Books
  • Conversion Therapy
  • Film
  • Gay Lives
  • Gender Dysphoria
  • Interviews
  • Lesbian and Gay News
  • Lesbian Lives
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Reports
  • Sponsored Editorial
  • Theatre
  • Transgender
  • Videos

About Us

Lesbian and Gay News is an alternative source of news and opinion. Lesbian and Gay News picks up from an historic tradition of British lesbian and gay publications such as Gay News, which ran from 1972-1983, and The Pink Paper, which ran for 25 years from 1987.

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Reports
  • Opinion
  • Interviews
  • Politics
  • Lesbian Lives
  • Gay Lives
  • Conversation
  • Videos
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up

© 2021 staging.lesbianandgaynews.com - BM Payments Services Limited

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.